Seared Grass Fed Sirloin
Ahhh, steak. The creme de la creme when you think of a “fancy” meal. There are plenty of nights where I crave a fatty cut of steak or a bolognese (in fact, I have a bolognese recipe… here), and I have a soft spot for skirt steak or short ribs. On other nights, a nice sirloin will do. I have to confess, I’ve never been a pro with making steak; I tend to overcook and make it inedible. It usually comes out tough and chewy, even when cutting against the grain. This steak is an exception to my “I screwed up the steak, again” curse, and it’s so easy you’ll slap yourself (but don’t).
One thing that I never compromise for is the quality of meat. It is SO important to know where your meat comes from, and get the best cuts. I always shop for grass-fed meats, and love using Butcher Box for meat. Their product is top notch and can feed a large family for a few weeks. You can skip a month, two months, and add specials like their bacon (THEIR BACON IS LIFE CHANGING) or burgers. Either way, consider buying grass fed meats, if there’s one thing you change to your budget, do this. I won’t bore you with science behind it or research from articles I’ve read and podcasts I’ve listened to, but the quality of meat matters. Period. Trader Joe’s does make solid grass fed meats, including steak.
I started by soaking the steaks in olive oil, instead of coating the pan with oil. Why? This eliminates the crackling and sputtering of the oil, that’s why sparky! For the seasoning, I used a more-than-generous amount of fresh cracked ground pepper and pink sea salt. I seasoned both sides and let the steak get to room temperature. Using a cast-iron skillet, I heated the pan then slowly added the steaks. These steaks were about 3/4″ -1″ thick so I gauged my time carefully. We like our steaks more medium/medium rare, so I seared the steaks for 4 minutes on each side, then threw it in the oven on BROIL for a good 5 minutes. For medium well, add 2-3 minutes per side. The most important piece is to LET THE STEAK REST. The steak will tense up if cut into right away, the same as man-handling it right out of the fridge. Let the steak do it’s thing!
I sliced small dollops of butter to top on the steaks for additional fat and goodness, and paired it with potatoes. Typical meat and potatoes dish, but oh so satisfying.